top of page
dimension
Length, in
Length, ft
Length, cm
Height, in
Height, cm
Height, ft
Weight, g
Weight, oz
Weight, lb
Detail Info
Object ID
1986.070.131
Access Number
1986.070
Subjects
Object Name
Photograph, Black & White
Other Name
Status
Material
Provenance
Location
Origin
Caption
Date
Status Date
Note
Dimension Notes
Condition Notes
FEATURE INFO
Artifact Type
Image
Image
Category
Collection
CANADA & CANADIAN EXPEDITIONARY FORCE
CANADA ET FORCE EXPÉDITIONNAIRE CANADIENNE
"Over the top at the Somme" training, October, 1916
"Over the Top"Official Caption: "Canadian troops 'going over the top' during training course at a trench-mortar school. This famous image was originally believed to have been taken at the front,but later proven to have actually been a composite of shell bursts at a trench-mortar school near St. Pol and rehearsal attacks".
Photo from album which possibly belonged to Lt Reginald Vigars Prenter (RVP), 72nd Bn.
"Over the top at the Somme" (in training area behind the lines) Famous photo often passed off as a combat shot, but man on right is thumbing his nose at another photographer who is out in front of him. It was actually taken in a training area behind the lines in a practice assault. Sometimes his hand is erased and possibly fake shellfire added in sky.
From the article "Beyond the Taking of Vimy Ridge: The War Photographs of William Ivor Castle" by Carla-Jean Stokes in Journal of Military and Strategic Studies, Volume 18, Issue 2, 2017. Article attached.
The first of these iconic images is [this] William Ivor Castles photograph, Over the Top. It depicts soldiers emerging from a trench, ostensibly going into battle. It was published widely during the war, and was shown during an exhibition of war photographs in London, although it was discovered to having been taken during a training session.6 This photograph continues to be used widely today including for recent Vimy Ridge centenary marketing campaigns although it is a photograph of soldiers training for the Somme with or without regard to its having been staged.

bottom of page

